Steak Sandwich with Herb Butter

This steak sandwich turns a handful of simple kitchen staples into a restaurant-worthy meal you can enjoy at home. The key is building layers of contrasting textures and flavors: golden toasted baguette, creamy havarti cheese, rich caramelized onions, and juicy, well-seasoned steak all brought together with a lavish swipe of homemade garlic-dill butter.

When I first decided to melt havarti over the steak, it was a happy accident at a busy dinner party. That choice alone sparked endless requests from friends for my “fancy steak sandwich night.”

Essential Ingredients and Selection

• Steak Choice: Ribeye is unbeatable for marbling and tenderness. For budget-friendly options, top sirloin or NY strip provide great flavor and slice easily. Look for bright red color and a fine grain when selecting your steak
• Baguette: A bakery-fresh loaf is worth the extra stop. A crisp, golden crust and soft interior make the sandwich sturdy and satisfying
• Havarti Cheese: This cheese melts beautifully and adds creaminess without overpowering. Always check for a fresh, creamy scent at the deli
• Onions: Sweet onions caramelize best and develop deep flavor. Choose ones that feel firm and heavy for their size
• Butter: Opt for European-style or high-fat butter for rich flavor and a perfect toast on your bread
• Seasonings: Good sea salt and freshly cracked pepper are essential. The meat’s natural flavors will sing with just a sprinkle

Step-by-Step Instructions

Prepare the Steak:

Allow your chosen steak to come to room temperature for even cooking. Generously season both sides with salt and pepper. Sear the steak over high heat until deeply browned on both sides, keeping it rare to medium-rare for tenderness. Let the steak rest for ten minutes before slicing thinly against the grain to ensure juicy, tender bites

Caramelize Onions:

Slice onions into even rings for uniform cooking. In the same pan used for steak, add a touch of butter and cook onions over low heat. Stir often until they’re golden and sweet, scraping up any browned bits for maximum flavor. This process can take twenty to thirty minutes for true caramelization

Make Herb Butter:

Soften butter, then mix in finely minced garlic and plenty of chopped fresh dill or parsley. Sprinkle in a little salt. This simple butter infuses the sandwich with aromatic flavor. Make extra and store for later

Assemble the Sandwich:

Slice the baguette lengthwise and spread the inside with herb butter. Toast under a broiler or in a hot pan until golden and fragrant. Stack sliced steak, caramelized onions, and a layer of havarti cheese on the toasted bread

Melt the Cheese:

Return the open sandwich to the broiler or oven until the cheese is completely melted and bubbling. Watch closely so the bread does not over-toast. Close the sandwich and cut it diagonally for presentation

Pin

Every time I make the garlic-dill butter, the scent fills the kitchen and brings back memories of my dad’s garden herbs. It is not just a small detail – it is honestly my favorite thing about this recipe. My kids love to help spread it onto the warm bread and it makes the whole meal feel special.

Storage Tips

Store leftover cooked steak and onions in separate airtight containers in the fridge. They will keep well for several days. Assemble sandwiches only when ready to eat so the bread stays crisp and cheese melty.

Ingredient Substitutions

For the steak, try skirt steak or even cooked chicken breast if you need a lighter option. Provolone, Swiss, or white cheddar swap in beautifully for havarti if that is what you have on hand. Parsley can stand in for dill in the butter, though it offers a milder herbal note.

Serving Suggestions

French fries or crisp potato chips make this feel like a diner or bistro meal. For something lighter, pair with a crunchy coleslaw or a salad of arugula, lemon, and parmesan. Quick pickled vegetables balance out the richness of the sandwich.

Pin

Cultural Context

The steak sandwich in its classic form is an anchor of diners and pubs around the world. This version celebrates both American steakhouse tradition and the café cultures of France and Denmark by layering classic ingredients in a fresh-baked baguette. The addition of herbed butter turns a simple meal into a memorable comfort food.

Recipe FAQs

→ What's the best cut of steak for this sandwich?

Ribeye is ideal for marbling and tenderness, while sirloin and strip steak offer flavorful, budget-friendly options. Thin slicing against the grain ensures a tender bite.

→ How do I get perfectly caramelized onions?

Cook thinly sliced onions slowly over medium heat, stirring occasionally, until they turn golden and sweet. Patience is key to drawing out their natural sugars.

→ Can I prepare the herb butter in advance?

Yes, herb butter can be made up to a week ahead and refrigerated. Bring to room temperature before spreading for best texture and flavor.

→ What cheese alternatives work well here?

Provolone, Swiss, Gruyere, or white cheddar all melt nicely and complement the steak’s richness, adding nuanced flavor notes.

→ How should I toast the bread for best texture?

Brush the inside with garlic butter before toasting to achieve a golden, crispy crust that adds savory depth and structure to the sandwich.

→ How do I ensure steak is cooked perfectly for the sandwich?

Bring steak to room temperature, season well, and sear quickly. Rest the meat before thin slicing to retain juices and tenderness.