Maine Style Lobster Rolls

A classic New England lobster roll brings me back to summer days on the Maine coast enjoying sweet lobster tucked into a buttery toasted bun. This recipe is all about celebrating that fresh flavor in its purest form with a zesty creamy dressing and just the right amount of crunch. Perfect for sharing with friends or a special lunch at home my family always lights up when these rolls hit the table.

I remember making these after a trip to Portland Maine and it instantly transported us all back to the sea breeze and picnic tables right by the water. Even my picky eater asks for seconds.

Ingredients

• Lobster meat: nothing beats real lobster for the signature taste Aim for a blend of claw and tail meat for great texture
• Celery: adds fresh crunch Use the light green center stalks for best flavor
• Chives: bring a mild onion flavor or you can use scallions for a bit more zip
• Fresh tarragon: gives a subtle anise lift Look for vibrant leaves
• Capers: add briny brightness Go for small tender capers and rinse if overly salty
• Lemon zest: wakes up the filling with citrus notes Always zest before juicing
• Lemon juice: brings acidity Squeeze it fresh
• Mayonnaise: creates creaminess Try to use high quality mayo for real depth
• Salt and black pepper: balance everything Freshly cracked pepper adds a pop
• Hot sauce or cayenne: for a gentle kick Optional but it really perks things up
• Unsalted butter: for warming lobster and toasting buns Rich flavor and classic touch
• New England style hot dog buns: split top shape holds filling best Look for soft yet sturdy buns or substitute with soft brioche

Step-by-Step Instructions

Prepare the Lobster Meat:

Place your cooked lobster meat in a strainer and let it drain You want to remove as much moisture as possible to keep the filling creamy not watery

Mix the Dressing:

In a large bowl combine chopped celery chives tarragon capers fresh lemon zest and juice mayonnaise a pinch of salt and black pepper plus hot sauce if you like Mix this together until evenly blended The dressing should be creamy but not soupy

Warm the Lobster:

Cut or tear the lobster meat into chunky bite sized pieces Double check for any small bits of shell or cartilage Heat one tablespoon of butter in a large skillet on medium until melted Add lobster meat and gently warm for about two minutes letting it soak up the butter If you love buttery flavor add a bit more

Combine Lobster with Dressing:

Using a slotted spoon transfer the warm lobster pieces into the bowl with the mayo dressing This keeps excess butter out of the mix Stir well until every piece is coated Taste and adjust seasoning if needed

Toast the Buns:

Pour out any leftover pan juices or use them in another recipe Wipe the skillet clean and return to medium heat Melt remaining butter and place buns cut side down Toast for one to two minutes until golden brown and crisp on both sides A good toast holds the filling and gives contrast

Fill and Serve:

Divide your lobster salad among the warm buns Pile it high for extra satisfaction Serve immediately with potato chips or crisp lettuce if you like

Pin

The lobster and tarragon pairing is what first made me fall for this recipe Fresh tarragon’s floral edge is my secret tip and always makes the rolls irresistible My youngest once licked his fingers for every last bit of the filling

Storage Tips

Keep extra lobster filling in an airtight container in the fridge for up to three days Fill the buns only right before eating to avoid sogginess If transporting bring filling and buns separately and assemble on site

Ingredient Substitutions

If lobster is not available substitute with cooked shrimp or langostino for a close flavor Butter can be swapped with ghee for a deeper taste For a lighter version use half Greek yogurt and half mayo

Pin

Serving Suggestions

Serve lobster rolls with classic kettle chips or a chilled cucumber salad For extra flair tuck in some crisp lettuce or scatter extra chives over the top A dill pickle spear on the side always makes the meal complete

Cultural Context

Lobster rolls have their roots in New England where lobster is plentiful and summer picnics near the ocean are a way of life The split top bun became popular because it perfectly cradles the filling giving that authentic touch Every bite is a taste of the coast

Recipe FAQs

→ What type of buns work best?

Split-top, New England-style buns are traditional, but soft hot dog buns or brioche also work well when toasted in butter.

→ Can I use frozen lobster meat?

Yes, just be sure to thaw and drain thoroughly to remove excess water before adding to your salad mixture.

→ What herbs complement lobster rolls?

Tarragon, chives, or scallions add fresh flavor. You can adjust herbs based on personal taste.

→ How do I store leftovers?

Keep extra lobster filling in an airtight container in the refrigerator and use within three days for best freshness.

→ Is it necessary to warm the lobster before assembling?

Warming the lobster in butter adds flavor, but you can skip this step if you prefer a cold, chilled filling.

→ Any alternatives to mayonnaise?

You can lighten with a mix of mayo and Greek yogurt, or swap in olive oil for less saturated fat.